Skip to content

FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OVER $25

New
Best Sellers
Ear
Plugs
Belly Rings
Septum
Nose
Face
Seasonal
Regular Jewelry
More
- Blog
- Last Chance
- Aftercare
- Basics
- Tools
- Dermal
- Nipple
  
  Barbells
  Captive Bead Rings
  Circular Barbells
  Non-Piercing

Facebook
Pinterest
Instagram
TikTok

Search

New
Best Sellers
Ear
Plugs
Belly Rings
Septum
Nose
Face
Seasonal
Regular Jewelry
More
- Blog
- Last Chance
- Aftercare
- Basics
- Tools
- Dermal
- Nipple
  
  Barbells
  Captive Bead Rings
  Circular Barbells
  Non-Piercing

Search

Collection: Cheater Plugs

Home
/
Cheater Plugs

Product type (0)

Product type

Plugs & Tunnels (22 products)
Cheater Plugs (22 products)

Plugs & Tunnels (22 products)

Gauge/Bar Thickness (0)

Gauge/Bar Thickness

1mm (18GA) (7 products)
1.2mm (16GA) (14 products)
20mm (13/16") (1 product)

1mm (18GA) (7 products)
1.2mm (16GA) (14 products)
20mm (13/16") (1 product)

Barbell/Diameter Length (0)

Barbell/Diameter Length

4mm (3/16") (2 products)
6mm (1/4") (20 products)
8mm (5/16") (3 products)

4mm (3/16") (2 products)
6mm (1/4") (20 products)
8mm (5/16") (3 products)

Material (0)

Metal Type

Stainless Steel (22 products)

Stainless Steel (22 products)

Material

Metal (20 products)
Acrylic (6 products)
Wood (2 products)

Metal (20 products)
Acrylic (6 products)
Wood (2 products)

Metal Type (0)

Metal Type

Stainless Steel (22 products)

Stainless Steel (22 products)

Color (0)

Color

Black (13 products)
Blue (5 products)
Brown (2 products)
Gold (2 products)
Green (3 products)
Pink (3 products)
Purple (2 products)
Rainbow (2 products)
Red (1 product)
Silver (14 products)
White (3 products)
Yellow (2 products)

Black (13 products)
Blue (5 products)
Brown (2 products)
Gold (2 products)
Green (3 products)
Pink (3 products)
Purple (2 products)
Rainbow (2 products)
Red (1 product)
Silver (14 products)
White (3 products)
Yellow (2 products)

Price

The highest price is $15.99

$

From

To

Threading (0)

Threading

External (6 products)

External (6 products)

Theme (0)

Theme

Halloween (1 product)
Pride (2 products)
Fall (1 product)

Halloween (1 product)
Pride (2 products)
Fall (1 product)

Piercing Location (0)

Lobe (9) Lobe (9 products)

Stretched Lobe (14) Stretched Lobe (14 products)

Piercing Location

Ear (22 products)

Ear (22 products)

Specific Location (0)

Specific Location

Lobe (9 products)
Stretched Lobe (14 products)

Lobe (9 products)
Stretched Lobe (14 products)

Plug/Tunnel/Earring Subtype (0)

Plug/Tunnel/Earring Subtype

Cheater Plugs (22 products)

Cheater Plugs (22 products)

Availability (0)

Availability

In stock (22 products)
Out of stock (3 products)

In stock (22 products)
Out of stock (3 products)

Singles/Sets (0)

Singles/Sets

Pair (22 products)

Pair (22 products)

Sort by:

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

22 products

Product type

Plugs & Tunnels (22 products)
Cheater Plugs (22 products)

Clear

Gauge/Bar Thickness

1mm (18GA) (7 products)
1.2mm (16GA) (14 products)
20mm (13/16") (1 products)

Clear

Barbell/Diameter Length

4mm (3/16") (2 products)
6mm (1/4") (20 products)
8mm (5/16") (3 products)

Clear

Material

Stainless Steel

Metal (20 products)
Acrylic (6 products)
Wood (2 products)

Clear

Color

Black (13 products)
Blue (5 products)
Brown (2 products)
Gold (2 products)
Green (3 products)
Pink (3 products)
Purple (2 products)
Rainbow (2 products)
Red (1 products)
Silver (14 products)
White (3 products)
Yellow (2 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $15.99

$

From

$

To

Clear

Threading

External (6 products)

Clear

Theme

Halloween (1 products)
Pride (2 products)
Fall (1 products)

Clear

Piercing Location

Lobe (9 products)
Stretched Lobe (14 products)
Ear (22 products)

Clear

Availability

In stock (22 products)
Out of stock (3 products)

Clear

Singles/Sets

Pair (22 products)

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

22 products

Sort by

Organic Sawo Wood Fake Pincher Taper Plugs - Stainless Steel

Organic Sawo Wood Fake Pincher T...

Regular price From $12.99

Regular price Sale price From $12.99
Unit price per
Electric Guitar Fake Taper Earrings - Stainless Steel - Pair

Electric Guitar Fake Taper Earri...

Regular price $13.99

Regular price Sale price $13.99
Unit price per
Glow In The Dark Owl Cheater Plugs - Stainless Steel

Glow In The Dark Owl Cheater Plu...

Regular price $9.99

Regular price Sale price $9.99
Unit price per
Organic Sawo Wood Fake Spiral Taper Plug Earrings - Pair

Organic Sawo Wood Fake Spiral Ta...

Regular price From $12.99

Regular price Sale price From $12.99
Unit price per
Green Alien UFO Fake Cheater Plugs Earrings - Stainless Steel

Green Alien UFO Fake Cheater Plu...

Regular price $9.99

Regular price Sale price $9.99
Unit price per
Star Shaped Fake Plugs - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Star Shaped Fake Plugs - Pair - ...

Regular price $13.99

Regular price Sale price $13.99
Unit price per

Lazy Girl Earrings 🥱😴

So comfy you'll forget they're there!

Shop Now!

Polished Fake 00GA Plugs - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Polished Fake 00GA Plugs - Pair ...

Regular price $9.99

Regular price Sale price $9.99
Unit price per
Pink Purple and Blue Striped Bisexual Pride Fake Cheater Plug Earrings - Stainless Steel - Pair

Pink Purple and Blue Striped Bis...

Regular price $13.99

Regular price Sale price $13.99
Unit price per
Playboy Bunny Logo Fake Cheater Plug Earrings - Stainless Steel

Playboy Bunny Logo Fake Cheater ...

Regular price $10.99

Regular price Sale price $10.99
Unit price per
Rainbow Striped Gay Pride Fake Cheater Plugs Earrings - Stainless Steel - Pair

Rainbow Striped Gay Pride Fake C...

Regular price $9.99

Regular price Sale price $9.99
Unit price per
Screw Bolt Fake Tapers - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Screw Bolt Fake Tapers - Pair - ...

Regular price $15.99

Regular price Sale price $15.99
Unit price per
Double Star Fake Plugs - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Double Star Fake Plugs - Pair - ...

Regular price $15.99

Regular price Sale price $15.99
Unit price per

Which Piercing Should You Get Next?

Take Our Quiz!

Black and White Multi Star Fake Plugs with Black O-RIngs - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Black and White Multi Star Fake ...

Regular price $14.99

Regular price Sale price $14.99
Unit price per
Acrylic Lightning Bolt Fake Hanging Taper Earrings - Pair

Acrylic Lightning Bolt Fake Hang...

Regular price $15.99

Regular price Sale price $15.99
Unit price per
Acrylic Yellow Spiral Fake Hanging Taper Earrings - Pair

Acrylic Yellow Spiral Fake Hangi...

Regular price $15.99

Regular price Sale price $15.99
Unit price per
Screw Bolt Fake Plugs - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Screw Bolt Fake Plugs - Pair - 3...

Regular price $15.99

Regular price Sale price $15.99
Unit price per
Teal and Pink Leopard Print Fake Plugs with Black O-RIngs - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Teal and Pink Leopard Print Fake...

Regular price $14.99

Regular price Sale price $14.99
Unit price per
Neon Acrylic Fake Plugs - Pair

Neon Acrylic Fake Plugs - Pair

Regular price $9.99

Regular price Sale price $9.99
Unit price per

Bunny Approved💋

Shop Now!

Acrylic Triple Skull Fake Plugs - Pair

Acrylic Triple Skull Fake Plugs ...

Regular price $12.99

Regular price Sale price $12.99
Unit price per
Star Center Fake Plugs with Black O-Rings - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Star Center Fake Plugs with Blac...

Regular price $13.99

Regular price Sale price $13.99
Unit price per
Star Center Fake 0GA Plugs - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Star Center Fake 0GA Plugs - Pai...

Regular price $13.99

Regular price Sale price $13.99
Unit price per
Fake 0GA Plugs with Black O-Rings - Pair - 316L Stainless Steel

Fake 0GA Plugs with Black O-Ring...

Regular price $9.99

Regular price Sale price $9.99
Unit price per

Explore More

Sign Up And Save

Sign up to be the first one to discover new collections, discounts and more!

Email address

Quick links

Home
Contact Us
About Us
Gift Cards
Collections
Shop All

Information

FAQ
Terms of Service
Return Policy
Shipping Info
Blogs
Partnerships

Follow Us

Facebook
Instagram
TikTok
Pinterest

My Account

Log In
Sign Up
View Cart

Payment methods

© 2025, piercedowl, All rights reserved.

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.